D What do you value in a paper replication? Context: Recently | Data Scientology

D What do you value in a paper replication?

Context: Recently read a paper from a few years back that I thought was pretty cool. Ended up replicating the implementation on github, because (1) I believe the idea should be made more accessible, and (2) as good old fashioned practice. Throughout the time spent working on it, replicating training results was dead last in priority, and I nearly forgot about it before considering the exercise complete.

Thus my curiosity: r/MachineLearning, what do you value in a paper replication?

P.S.: Might as well link the repo while I'm here. Happy to hear any feedback!

/r/MachineLearning
https://redd.it/v100ix