Issue: A person of bidaʿh who becomes a kāfir due to his bidaʿ | IlmTest

Issue: A person of bidaʿh who becomes a kāfir due to his bidaʿh, there is no problem if his narrations are rejected,
" مسئلة ": المبتدع إن كفر ببدعته، فلا إشكال في رد روايته.

But if he does not become a kāfir with it but legalizes lying, his reports will also be rejected.
وإذا لم يكفر، فإن استحل الكذب رُدت أيضاً،

But if he does not legalize lying, is it acceptable or not?
وإن لم يستحل الكذب، فهل يقبل أو لا؟

Should there be a distinction as to if he calls to his bidaʿh or not?
أو يفرق بين كونه داعية أو غير داعية؟

There is a great difference of views about that, old and present.
في ذلك نزاع قديم وحديث.

But the position of the majority of the scholars is as regard if he invites to his bidaʿh or not.
والذي عليه الأكثرون التفصيل بين الداعية وغيره،

There is a report from (al-Imām) al-Shāfīʿī about that.
وقد حكي عن نص الشافعي.

Ibn Kathīr, al-Bāʿith al-Ḥadith ʾIlá Ikhtiṣār ʿUlūm ʾl-Ḥadīth 1/99
ابن كثير، الباعث الحثيث إلى اختصار علوم الحديث ١/٩٩
https://shamela.ws/book/21571/83

@ilmtest [https://t.me/ilmtest]